A Comparison of Economic and Operational Tradeoffs for the Deployment of Broadcast, Multicast, and Unicast Infrastructures within an IP Video Environment (2012)

By Carol Ansley, Jim Allen, Tom Cloonan, ARRIS

As the Cable Industry evaluates the incorporation of IP Video as the next stage of video delivery, an important consideration is the need for analogues of the current Broadcast, Switched, and Unicast protocols within the IP Video deployments. Initially, it was assumed that the new IP Video world would look much like the current Legacy Video world, with its own architecture based on a triplet of protocols- one for Broadcasted (always-on Multicast) video, one for Switched (Multicast) Video, and one for Unicast Video.

As the industry has continued to traverse the complex learning curve, this fundamental understanding has come into question.

Arguments have been made for the elimination of Broadcast, based on the idea that a Multicast deployment would provide increased network efficiencies. An opposing viewpoint is that a small Broadcast tier coupled together with a Unicast tier might provide greater network simplicity by eliminating the need for (and complexities of) a Multicast tier. This paper will use simulations based upon subscriber behavior to explore design approaches for several possible deployment scenarios. The analysis would consider network efficiency, possible economic factors, and possible feature interactions in an effort to help guide MSO decisions as they move forward towards future IP Video deployments.

By clicking the "Download Paper" button, you are agreeing to our terms and conditions.

Similar Papers

Architectural Alternatives For Cable Ip Video
By Jeff Brooks, Carol Ansley, Tom Cloonan, Stephen Kraiman, Dan Torbet, ARRIS
Mobile TV: A Technical And Economic Comparison Of Broadcast, Multicast And Unicast Alternatives And The Implications For Cable
By Michael Eagles, UPC Broadband and Tim Burke, Liberty Global Inc.
Architectural Approaches to Help Circumvent the “Simulcast Roadblock” of IP Video Deployments
By T. Cloonan, J. Allen, C. Ansley, R. Arnold, J. Brooks, M. Bugajski, C. Cheevers, T. Cotter, J. Howe, B. Hanks, D. Torbet, M. Uecker, & I. Wheelock, ARRIS
An Improvement Proposal For The Timing And Scaling Of DOCSIS IP Multicast Services
By William T. Hanks, Tom Cloonan, Amit Eshet, Jeff Howe, John Ulm, Ian Wheelock, ARRIS
Unicast or Multicast for IP Video? Yes!
By John Horrobin, Yoav Schreiber, Cisco Systems
Multicast As A Mandatory Stepping Stone For An IP Video Service To The Big Screen
By Amit Eshet, John Ulm, Uzi Cohen, Carol Ansley, ARRIS
Real-Time Analytics for IP Video Multicast
By Dr. Claudio Righetti, Emilia Gibellini, Florencia De Arca, Mariela Fiorenzo & Gabriel Carro, Telecom Argentina
Moving To An All-IP, All-AVC HFC Access: Opportunities And Challenges
By Carol Ansley and Mark Bugajski, ARRIS Group
Deploying IP Video Services, Architectures and Technologies
By Eduardo M. Panciera Molanes, Adrian Grimaldi, Norberto Harmath, Gaston Diaz & Marcos Aberastury, Telecom S.A.
IP Multicast In Cable Networks
By Joe Godas, Brian Field, Alon Bernstein, Sanjeev Desai, Toerless Eckert, and Harsh Parandekar
More Results >>